The eggshell plaintiff rule means a person who causes an injury cannot avoid responsibility simply because the injured person was unusually vulnerable to harm. In California, a defendant can be responsible for harm their wrongful conduct caused even if a healthier person would have suffered less or no injury in the same circumstances. For example, an existing bone condition may help explain why a collision caused a particularly serious fracture.
The rule does not make a defendant responsible for every health problem that existed before the accident. A claim must still distinguish prior symptoms from new injury or worsening caused by the incident. Earlier and later medical records can help explain that difference. The FAQ on an insurer’s medical-record release addresses the separate practical issue of handling a records request when medical history is relevant.
